ESSEX: 'Don't over-tutor your child to get a grammar place'

Trusted article source icon
Sunday, March 27, 2011
Profile image for This is Essex

This is Essex

ESSEX children taking the 11-plus exam should not be intensively tutored, according to the board that produces the annual test.

With more than three times as many pupils now applying for the available places at the county's eight grammar schools, there is added pressure on families to ensure their child is fully prepared to gain a coveted place.

Often the message spread among parents is that unless a child is privately tutored for at least a year, they will have no hope of gaining enough marks.

But the Consortium of Selective Education in Essex, the body that sets and administers the annual test, says otherwise.

Nicole Chapman, head teacher of Chelmsford County High School for Girls, who is this year's CSSE spokesman, says long-term coaching is counter-productive.

She told the Chronicle: "What we all agree as head teachers of grammar schools is that children should have familiarised themselves with the format of the paper, and been shown examples of previous years' tests, but intensive coaching is counter-productive in the sense that if they are simply trained to give a mechanical response to the questions they will not cope with grammar school."

Mrs Chapman recommends parents consult their child's teacher early on in their junior school career on whether he or she would be suitable for a grammar school

She said: "A child who is curious about the world; who wants to read books and newspapers; likes going to museums and finding out about the world: that is a grammar school child."

The 11-plus English and maths papers are written by Essex grammar school staff and checked by colleagues. The verbal reasoning paper is set by an outside company.

"We believe the papers should be rigorous enough to select the children who can manage the demanding curriculums at our schools."

Prior to joining Chelmsford County High four years ago, Mrs Chapman was a head teacher in Kent, where 25 per cent of children go to selective schools, and there is a grammar school in every major town.

"The signs are that there are far more people in Essex wanting to go to grammar schools than there are grammar school places," said Mrs Chapman.

"There is no doubt that parents would like more grammar school places in the county.

"However, my colleagues at the comprehensives would clearly challenge this because they want to keep the more able children in their schools.

"With 800 applicants for 120 places, inevitably there will be some children who are not here but should be.

"It is hard for those who just miss out on a place, but these academically capable children will do just as well at another school."

One major criticism of the two Chelmsford grammar schools is that they have no catchment area, so Essex pupils are competing for places with those from London boroughs and neighbouring counties such as Hertfordshire and Suffolk.

Mrs Chapman said the schools' admission policies have always been based on pupils who get the best results, but she does warn parents not to send their child to a school a long distance from home.

She said: "We expect parents and girls to be a part of the school community and if they cannot make it to before-school clubs or stay for activities after lessons or in the evenings, then there is a problem."

5
Tweet this article
Report

5 Comments

  • Profile image for Sujit

    by Sujit

    Tuesday, October 18 2011, 2:52PM

    “Sorry this comment is late but I am looking to place my daughter into a Grammer school and I totally agree with Parvinder in that the state schools really have to pull their socks up. Every borough should have at least two grammar schools to accomodate certain children but at the same time improve the national "average" curricullum so that parents are encouraged to send their children to a decent state school.
    Sujit”

  • Profile image for This is Essex

    by Parvinder, Essex

    Wednesday, March 30 2011, 4:30PM

    “With the rapidly declining standards in today's comps, decent parents are almost forced to try and get their children into grammar schools. If state secondaries weren't so downright awful, this problem would not arise. The truth is children can only get a quality education in either grammar or private schools. That is an indictment on the state system, which is terrible.”

  • Profile image for This is Essex

    by Carol,, Essex

    Tuesday, March 29 2011, 3:41PM

    “My son is one of those children 'who just missed out'. He went to a state primary and had just two months practise. If we had been in catchment for Southend he would be in, we live just outside - on the bus route for SHSB and he would of actually had to walk less to get to that school than the local comp - which is fortunately very good. My main gripe is that there will boys who live just a couple of miles down the road who scored less but got in due to the catchment area criteria that the Southend grammers enforce.
    Over tutoring is a big problem as it makes grammer schools elitist, only those children whose parents can afford private tutoring getting in - this is unfortunately a fact and inevitably some of those children will not cope.”

  • Profile image for This is Essex

    by Raj, Essex

    Tuesday, March 29 2011, 12:17PM

    “Couldn't agree more, Parvinder. Looking just at the secondary schools in Brentwood, they really are of a poor standard. Look at Shenfield High School, once a good school, now the absolute dregs. Any parent who cares about their child's education, will do their utmost to get them into a grammar school, or, if they can afford it, a private school.
    State education has hit rock bottom.”

  • Profile image for This is Essex

    by Parvinder, Essex

    Monday, March 28 2011, 9:38PM

    “When you consider just what a rotten so-called 'education' is on offer at comprehensives, you can't blame parents for trying to get their kids into grammar schools.
    Every town should have at least one grammar school to help offset the lousy comps.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters